- a failed takeover bid(for Kohinoor Foods)
- an income tax raid(resulting in 9Crores+ additional accepted tax demand)
- Failure to pay the EMI for acquired company(Karen Anand foods)
- Doubts of windowdressing the books due to rapid growth(to its credit the company is clean..on paper)
- Its annual report-full of irrelevant drivel, pictures and quotations.
- Its MD's flamboyant lifestyle(it IS none of my concern but has affected the company as appears below).
But having an independent director/key management personnel with doubtful antecedents is not unique to Temptation Foods. In several other Indian companies, you see some/all of these features
- 40-50yr olds, part of the key management, drawing salary<10Lakhs(or at times even below 5 Lakh Rs). And this is without any options...
- Independent directors with irrelevant expertise(for this purpose I would justify business expertise(in that industry), supplier/client experience, financial, legal and tax expertise as relevant). How can actors, ex police officers etc add any value?
- Directors independent in name only where a cursory internet search throws up details of their friendships with the promoter/CEO. I do not say that the two should keep an arm's length, but the independence is compromised due to friendship.
- Not disclosing the remuneration statement of employees drawing>Rs 2Lakh/month-the shareholder must demand it from the company.
- Run a sanity check on industry pay scales to justify the low pay for KMP
- Resignations of directors(past and recent)
- Arrests/Tax Raids/Litigation against the company/its management
- Bulletin boards devoted to pumping and critiquing the company-BOTH are quite helpful specially the ones on moneycontrol, Rediff Money
- Blog posts written on the company
No comments:
Post a Comment